Riding the Energy Rollercoaster
Mastering the Shift from Volatile Producers to Steady Midstreams and Royalties
A Cycle-Savvy Guide to Building and Preserving Wealth in Oil & Gas
In the wild world of commodities, where oil and natural gas prices swing like a pendulum, timing isn’t just everything—it’s the difference between building wealth and watching it evaporate. Today, we’re diving into a timeless strategy for navigating the oil and natural gas cycle: starting with undervalued producers during the troughs, riding the bull market waves, and then pivoting to the stability of midstream companies and royalty trusts when the party starts winding down. This isn’t about day-trading or chasing headlines; it’s about disciplined, cycle-aware investing that preserves capital and generates reliable income.
Commodities like oil and natural gas are inherently cyclical, driven by supply-demand imbalances, geopolitical events, technological shifts, and even weather patterns. Think of it as a predictable (yet unpredictable in timing) loop: oversupply leads to price crashes, which force production cuts, eventually tightening the market and sparking a rally. The key? Knowing where you are in that cycle. Miss the signs of a peak, and you could ride a producer stock straight into a bear market abyss. Spot it early, and you lock in gains before shifting to lower-risk plays.
The Producer Play: Buying Low and Riding High (But Not Too Long)
Let’s start at the bottom of the cycle. When oil or natural gas prices dip below the average cost of production—think $40-60 per barrel for oil in many U.S. shale plays or $2-3 per MMBtu for natural gas—you’re looking at a prime entry point for upstream producers. These are the companies drilling wells, extracting resources, and selling directly into the market. Think ExxonMobil.
Why buy then? Producers are essentially selling at a loss, leading to bankruptcies, reduced drilling, and eventual supply shortages that ignite a bull market. As prices recover, their margins explode—revenues soar while fixed costs stay relatively stable, creating massive upside volatility. You buy consistently through the rally, dollar-cost averaging into the strength, and scale out as the bull matures. This leverages the commodity’s direct tie to global quality of life: energy demand isn’t going away; it’s foundational to everything from heating homes to powering industries.
Risks: Producers are highly volatile: their fortunes are tethered to commodity prices. A sudden OPEC+ production hike, a mild winter curbing gas demand, or a global recession can tank prices overnight. Hold too long, and you risk capital destruction. Past crashes (like 2014-2016 and 2020) saw producer shares plummet 70-90%.
Tools for discipline: Monitor leading indicators like inventory levels (EIA reports), futures curves (contango vs. backwardation), and drilling activity (Baker Hughes rig counts). As of October 2025, natural gas is around $3-4/MMBtu and oil $60-70/barrel—mid-cycle phase, but watch for oversupply signals from Permian expansions.
Pivoting to Stability: Midstream Companies
As the bull market crests—signaled by sustained high prices encouraging overproduction—shift to companies that profit from volume rather than price. Enter midstream players, the “toll roads” of the energy sector.
What is a midstream energy company? In oil and natural gas, midstream refers to the logistics backbone: transporting, storing, processing, and sometimes fractionating raw hydrocarbons from production sites to refineries or end-users. For oil, this includes crude pipelines, tankers, and storage terminals. For natural gas, it’s gathering lines, processing plants, compression stations, and interstate pipelines.
Pros:
Fee-based revenues: Long-term, take-or-pay contracts where shippers pay fixed fees regardless of commodity prices.
Essential infrastructure: High barriers to entry due to regulations and capital intensity, creating moats.
Dividend appeal: Often structured as MLPs (Master Limited Partnerships) with yields of 5-8%.
Cons:
Volume risks: If upstream production drops, throughput declines, hurting fees.
Regulatory and environmental hurdles: Pipeline approvals can face delays or cancellations; ESG pressures are rising.
Capex demands: Maintaining infrastructure and expansions require ongoing investment.
Predictable income and low volatility: Contracts often span 10-20 years with minimum volume commitments, insulating against price swings. Earnings are more like utilities—steady and boring—than boom-bust producers. In downturns, midstreams might dip 20-30% versus producers’ 50-70%. During rallies, they offer solid gains with less drama.
The Royalty Route: Passive Income from the Ground Up
For even more hands-off stability, consider royalty companies—essentially landlords of the subsurface.
What is a royalty company in oil and natural gas? These entities own mineral rights or overriding royalty interests (ORRIs) on producing lands but don’t operate the wells. They collect a percentage of revenues from oil or gas sales without bearing exploration, drilling, or operating costs.
Pros:
No operational costs: Pure upside from production, diversified across operators and basins.
Scalability: Growth as lessees drill more, with no additional investment.
Tax advantages: Often pass-through entities with high distributions.
Cons:
Dependency on operators: If a producer goes bankrupt or halts drilling, royalties dry up.
Reserve depletion: Finite resources mean eventual decline unless new leases are acquired.
Price exposure: Still fluctuate with commodity prices, though often hedged.
Predictable income and low volatility: Income from royalties on existing production, often under long-term leases with built-in escalators. Diversified portfolios smooth out individual failures. Volatility is lower than producers, and many yield 4-7% dividends.
Personal Twist and Final Thoughts
Personally, I hold onto midstream and royalty positions indefinitely for reliable income as long as the companies remain in good standing—think quarterly dividends funding the next play or reinvesting the dividends. When producers hit rock-bottom (below production costs), I deploy fresh capital, avoiding the temptation to sell stable assets. This compounds over cycles: producers for growth, midstreams/royalties for income.
Don’t forget geopolitical wildcards, the ongoing energy transition, and inflation hedges.
Taxes matter—MLPs can trigger complex K-1 forms, so consult advisors.
Cycles vary by basin; patience and discipline are your superpowers.
Upgrade to paid and unlock the companies we love with handpicked mining companies, energy plays and much more. With full breakdown and why they are great companies. Answering the unknown questions before they become answers.
